The duress defense in California can excuse a crime that a person committed only because someone else threatened them. It is a narrow defense with specific requirements.
Duress is not the same as self-defense, and it is not the same as the "economic duress" idea used in contract disputes. This article explains what criminal duress is, when it applies, and when it does not. Goss Law can help with other questions like Can you threaten to sue someone California?
What Is the Duress Defense?
Under Penal Code 26 and the California jury instruction on duress (CALCRIM 3402), a person is not guilty of a crime if they committed it under duress. The defense has these elements:
- Someone demanded that the defendant commit a crime.
- That person threatened the defendant (or someone else) to make them do it.
- The defendant actually believed their life, or another person's life, would be in immediate danger if they refused.
- That belief was reasonable.
- The crime was not murder.
Threats of future harm are not enough. The danger has to be immediate. Once there is evidence of duress, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act under duress.
How Effective Can This Defense Be?
Duress can be a complete defense when the facts fit. The challenge is often evidence. Text messages, recordings, witnesses, or video showing the threat and the demand can be key. A lawyer will look at whether the evidence supports each element before deciding whether to raise it.
Duress Is Not Self-Defense
Self-defense applies when someone uses force to protect themselves from an attack. The idea that a person's reaction must be in proportion to the threat belongs to self-defense. Duress is different: it applies when a person commits a crime because someone threatened them into doing it. If someone threatens to punch another person and that person responds by shooting them, duress is not the right defense.
Duress Is Not a Defense to Murder
Duress cannot be used as a defense to murder. Lawful self-defense, on the other hand, is a complete defense to a homicide. A killing in lawful self-defense is a justifiable homicide, which is not murder.
What About "Economic Duress" and "Emotional Duress"?
"Economic duress" is a civil contract concept. It can be used to undo an agreement or payment that was forced by wrongful threats. It is not a defense to criminal charges. Situations like scams, ransom demands, or one spouse pressuring another for money are civil or victim situations, not criminal duress defenses.
Why Duress Is Sometimes Underutilized by Attorneys
Duress usually means the defense does not dispute that the defendant did the act, and instead argues that the threat excuses it. That can be a hard strategic choice when the evidence of the threat is thin, so some attorneys pursue other defenses first. A criminal defense law firm in Sacramento can look at whether duress or another defense fits the facts.
Final Thoughts
A crime committed under duress can be excused in some cases, but only when the defendant reasonably believed their life (or another person's life) was in immediate danger if they refused, and never when the charge is murder. Because the requirements are strict and the evidence matters, anyone thinking about this defense should talk to a lawyer about the facts of their case.
Need help with a case in Sacramento? Read about my criminal defense work, or tell me what happened.
This post is general information about California law, not legal advice about your situation. Laws change, and every case is different. For advice about your case, talk to a lawyer.